prob dont have to give up that much draft capital being he failed his medical and stripped of the C.

That would get its for the Sabres, I actually think it's too much for the Rangers. The picks and Robertson are what the Sabres need. And more important next season, lots of cap to obtain players.
Georgiev and Strome even he traded at TDL, more pieces.

No it wouldnt. The Sabres dont need Robertson at all, especially not at the cost of Eichel. The Sabres have cap room with Eichel on the roster and wont attract free agents anyway so that has no added value

If it were up to you the Sabres wouldn't trade Jack for Jesus Christ himself. Enough already

I never said that, I've agreed with many many trades on here as well. Again you have no idea, because you never bothered to read, just assumed

Sabres shouldn't sell low on Eichel

define sell low?
also, what would you consider an appropriate trade today (not 6 months ago/not 6 months from now)?

Acquiring Eichel basically puts us in the same place we are now, next season. Mika walks, we have no 2C. It's too much money to add. Strome is a fine 2C. If Mika doesn't start cold, by the end of the year we won't feel the need to add Jack. We're in a good spot. We don't have to go after him just because he's available. It doesn't make sense.

OIlers wouldnt accept that trade tho either

Eichel being stripped of the C means absolutely nothing.

Buffalo wants an equivalent of four firsts. Right now, I doubt they get that. I think a fair trade RIGHT NOW is the equivalent of three firsts. So, from NY it would be Kakko, Chytil and a 22 1st.

I think we’re gonna need an improvement over Strome at 2C if we want to be a serious team this year and into the future but I don’t think Eichel is the answer. Too much risk from the injury and how it will affect us financially.

I think the trade you proposed is a very fair offer.
But most NYR ACGM do not think Kakko will be part of any trade.
If I were the Sabre GM I would rather have Kravtsov, Lundqvist, and a 22 first.
I actually think the offer will be Strome, Kakko, Georgiev, 22 first

Strome was a top 15 Center in terms of points last season. What kind of improvement are you looking for? I think he's proved he belongs there. We'll know for sure by the end of this season.