Quoting: Alfie11
I think this is an incredibly hot take. Calling each of those guys a 60 point guy is generous seeing how neither of the wingers have actually hit 60 points since 2015 (and while Schwartz was on pace for 66 in 19-20 he was on pace for 43 this year and in 18-19), and McCann's career high is 35 points. I do think McCann will breakout, but a breakout for him would be 60 points. Maybe one or two of them hit 70 points, but most teams can field a better line even if these three combine for 200 points. This would be an elite 2nd line, but it's not a great 1st line. Also calling Tatar-Danault-Gallagher a top 5 line is a huge stretch as well, it's not better than Boston, Colorado, Tampa, Vegas, Edmonton, Toronto, Pittsburgh, Chicago, Carolina, etc. offensively and most are more than capable defensively, which is secondary for a top line regardless. Same deal goes for ranking Seattle's top line, they simply don't have the firepower, even with a breakout season for McCann, to hang with other top lines offensively, and being a good shutdown line is something you want for your 2nd or 3rd line, you want your 1st line to light up the scoreboard. Like the Tkachuk-Backlund-Frolik line of a few years ago was not a top 15 line because they were great defensively and scored 70 goals, they were just a good 2nd line.
Context matters. McCann was on pace for 61 points last season averaging 14 min of ice time. He’ll be playing 1st line minutes with better linemates this season. I think he’s a lock for 60-65 points this season. Eberle and Schwartz should be 55-60 pt guys as well. The line will score goals at a borderline elite rate and they won’t give up much because of their elite defensive play. Their goal share should be between 55-60% which would be a top 15 1st line.
Tkachuk-Backlund-Frolik were only a great line in 18-19 when they played 48 games together. They scored 4 goals per 60 minutes which is a 1st line rate.
Tatar-Danault-Gallagher was a top 5 1st line and neither of them were PPG players. This is MTL compared to BOS 1st line