Dermott isn't nearly as good as leafs fans think he is, a 6th rounder should be able to get you Dermott, what you proposed is a massive overpay

Sens say YES YES YES

I'd rather play Andy Green than waste assets on Dermott

Andy Greene is one of the worst defenseman in the NHL

he’s not that bad, he’s just old and probably overused.

The last time he was good was during the 2020 playoffs in the bubble. He was awful last season, he can barely skate , can’t move the puck at all. At even strength he’s a complete liability. It’s understandable , the guy is 40 years old

I never get tired of people on the internet who are smarter than Lou Lamoriello.... the guy who just signed him again.

Lou isn’t infallible , he’s a solid GM but he likes his guys. The islanders are significantly worse whenever Greene is on the ice at even strength , that is a fact

I guess Barry Trotz is guilty of having the same fault. It's a shame we have all these people sitting at home who are smarter than HOF hockey executives and coaches. If only you were running the show, maybe the Islanders could have done better the last two years.

I hear the real smart people think the Islanders should add Dermott....

He definitely is - great coaches/GMs can make mistakes. The numbers don’t lie, Greene is awful.

Yes. Lou Lamoriello and Barry Trotz are wrong and you are right.

lol good try. Guy wins pucks battles and sucks at everything else at even strength. 33rd percentile in even strength defense 👀💯 . Isles allow more quality scoring chances when he’s on the ice.

The New York Islanders have re-signed Andy Greene to one-year deal with $750K plus $250K in bonuses. Greene is just veteran replacement-level defenseman. pic.twitter.com/kzkt2DUnc0

— Andy & Rono 📊 (@HockeyStatsCZ) July 17, 2021