Quoting: Meeqs
The gap between the player people THINK Kessel is and who he actually is is astounding.
Unless you have a system that lets him cherry pick constantly and can feed him top end PP time the dude will just be a large net negative. Col can do neither of those things
I understand saying this will make people who don't understand Kessel super well, completely disregard everything I say, BUT I actually think Compher would provide a better chance of winning than Kessel would
The guy is at the absolute bottom on the league in PP contribution, Penalty issues and is one of the biggest defensive liabilities in the entire NHL. He is a guy who provides nothing other than his shot and is a massive detriment everywhere else. IF you are a team completely devoid of talent like ARZ then that can provide some use, but for good contending teams they can't take that trade off
I guess an example for Colorado fans to better understand the reality of the situation here. Imagine Iginla in the last year of his deal but worse
See here's the thing: Avs do have a system, and even a line, that's tailor made for him to cherry pick. Put him on the 3rd line with Nichuskin and Jost and he can cherry pick all he likes because those two are going to cover everything defensively and drive possession. Nichuskin-Jost-Donskoi was #1 in the entire NHL in xGF% and Corsi last year, I'm sure they'd manage just fine having Kessel on that line instead of Donskoi.
As for PP time. He's not getting on PP1, but we could certainly use a RHS who can shoot from the top of the circles.
------- Landeskog -----------
Mack -- Kadri -- Rantanen
--------- Makar ----------------
-------- Nichuskin/Compher ------
Kessel ------------------ Burakovsky
---------- Girard --- Toews -----------