Gagner and Murray are interesting inclusions.

Prime Erik Karlsson was a top 5 all time defenceman. It’s a shame how injuries screwed him over. I think he still has it in him to be an elite defenceman once again.

Murray is in his mid-20s now and only had 1 good full season, and 1.5 good Playoff runs. Miller, Price, Lundqvist were far superior goalies in their primes.

Indeed, I’d put Parise or Bobby Ryan over Gagner and Halak or Craig Anderson over Murray

Yeah but Miller is retired so he can’t be added to an AGM team, and everyone knows Price and Hank were franchise goalies in their prime

If Quick is on the team then Price and Hank should be on it well ahead of Murray. Miller played last year and was a shell of his prime, so it wasn't a stretch for me to have him. Rask, Rinne, Bishop in their primes blow Murray away too.

Crawford is a goalie that never really got his due.

I disagree with Price being on this list, because the kids seem to think he’s the best goalie in the NHL right now

They haven't watched him recently outside the Playoffs then. He's nowhere near the player he was before the MCL injury in 15-16.

Yes that is true.

Also, while we are on the topic of goalies, one of the most underrated goalies people forget was an absolute stud in net is Miikka Kiprusoff. Kipper was a top 5 goalie in the league for almost his entire tenure with the Flames, among the likes of Brodeur, Luongo and Hank. Not to mention, he and Iggy both single handedly carried the Flames to six straight playoff berths in the mid to late 2000s.

And Antoine Roussel lol

Thornton and Marleau were just unreal too. Carried mediocre SJ teams (and DW's job) season after season to cup contention.

Murray in the back to back cups was unstopable.