That’s probably a fair trade, although from the rumours it sounds like it might end up being much more favourable to Chicago.

Heck, I'm a Hawks fan...so I'm for that, but I want to hear what the EDM fans have to say and take it into consideration.

To be completely honest...I wouldn't be surprised at all if Keith supplanted Nurse on the Top Pair. It's not what I'm predicting...I just wouldn't be surprised. It's not Keith's fault he was training 5 different rookies last year.

This is one of the dumbest things I’ve ever read. So you’re making a bold statement but then backing off it. Nurse was 7th in Norris voting there’s zero chance Keith over takes nurse on the depth chart.

All I said was "wouldn't be surprised". I'm not sure how bold something can be when it's "wouldn't be surprised"....

So you don’t think it will happen but wouldn’t be surprised if it did? Is that your actual thought? How does that make sense?

Yes, You never know what's going to happen...until it happens. That's how all of life works. If in 1 year Keith leads all EDM dmen in ATOI...I'd say. Hmmm, ok. I didn't predict that, but I'm not shocked either.

Have you ever had an "I wouldn't bet on it, but I wouldn't bet against it either" epiphany?

You sound just as stupid

lol

EDM accepts, but I don't think the Hawks would make that trade because they don't save anything against the cap here. If they trade Keith, they obviously looking for a replacement (Jones, Hamilton) and need some cap space. I like the trade from an Oilers perspective though.