CapFriendly Bot: Thread moved to appropriate forum

wrong forum imo

1. Makar
2. Hedman
3. Josi
4. Theodore
5. Pietrangelo

Nurse instead of McAvoy

1. Hedman
…
…
…
2. Makar
3. Heiskanen
4. McAvoy
5. Fox

I used your top 5 d to make my top 5

hedman makar petro mcavoy fox/josi i’d accept either for 5 tbh

lol

I think makar, fox, mcavoy, and Hedman all deserve to be there. I don’t think dougie or Miro belong in the conversation. I think dougie was the third best d man on the hurricanes frankly. Slavin definitely deserves to be in that conversation. Josi also in there.

Weegar not mentioned

I can understand not having mcavoy so high because he hasn’t really had the offensive explosion (except the one time he was on PP1, this years playoffs), but he and nurse might as well be in a different league.

I have fox above Mcavoy due to his better offensive abilities as he is not to far off from Makar but the rest be the same

With very good reason.

Makar
Mcavoy
Fox
Hamilton
Hedman

If you've ever watched hockey you'd have a reason

Top ES defenseman point scorer + top 3 defensive defenseman in the NHL

When he’s the best defensemen on his team, maybe we’ll chat.

i knew i was forgetting someone my fault , hes def up there

hes absolutely up there and is better than ekblad

Swap out slavin for hamilton (or about 20 other guys), and i think that’s the list.

You were forgetting a couple guys, but it wasn’t weegar.

no it definitely was

Hes not in the top 30.

watch hockey that isnt the bruins lol , weegar is most definitely and upper echelon defenceman

Good one! Never heard that before. I like how you tossed on lol because you knew it wasn’t clever, and needed a cue. Weegar is a good player. He’s not a number one on any good team.

I think the guys in the discussion are
Makar
McAvoy
Fox
Hedman
Josi
Hamilton
Slavin
Chabot
Weegar
Toews
Carlson
Pietrangelo
Theodore
Heiskanen
Chychrun
Pulock