Not sure how some of these guys. Harpur, Coburn, Holden, Maroon, Ennis, Brassard fall into either category I don't think people rate them highly or expect much out of them anymore.
Like for the Oilers most disappointing player this year has been Yamamoto. He was super hot last year but this year despite all his good work and play the kid just can't produce at that same level this year.
Geiss has almost identical stats this year behind a bad detroit team as he did last year behind an islanders playoff team. Dudes done a good job this year.