Rejoint: janv. 2018
Messages: 16,884
Mentions "j'aime": 11,896
Idk I don't have a lot of time for back up goalies or 25 year olds in the Calder Conversation, so I'd probably rework that imo. I don't think guys who are in the prime of their career, with 6-8 years of Professional hockey experience should really be allowed to be considered rookies.
As far as goalies go, maybe it's an anti goalie bias, but as far as I'm concerned, if you're not getting a starter workload you shouldn't be in that conversation. If Connor McDavid can't win playing just 45/82 games, I have a hard time putting goalies who will play like 32 games in a full season into the mix.
If I were to put a top 5 out for this year, I'd probably have:
Kaprizov
Robertson
Shesterkin (though I still think he should be too old)
Norris
Smith