Forums/NHL Trades

(DET/WSH) - Mantha for Pánik, Vrána, 2021 1st, 2022 2nd

Who won the trade?
Le graphique a été masqué

Options de sondage

12 avr à 15 h 57
Rejoint: jan 2018
Messages: 12,056
Mentions "j'aime": 7,433
I was pretty meh on the return when I saw Vrana + Panik, but once I saw there was a 1st and 2nd as well, my jaw hit the floor. Absolutely nuts
BCAPP, gretzkyghosts, jpsnow13 and 2 others a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 15 h 58
Rejoint: jan 2018
Messages: 12,056
Mentions "j'aime": 7,433
Quoting: Laniccal
gretzkyghosts a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 15 h 58
Rejoint: fév 2019
Messages: 8,104
Mentions "j'aime": 2,863
2nd to dump Panik

Vrana and a first for Mantha.

Vrana and Mantha are pretty equal, tip of the hat to Mantha.... the other part is a cap dump.
DDoverChucky, jpsnow13, gretzkyghosts and 1 other person a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 15 h 58
Black Lives Matter
Rejoint: mar 2017
Messages: 29,584
Mentions "j'aime": 4,326
I don't understand this trade for Washington. Detroit wins IMO.
12 avr à 15 h 59
Rejoint: jun 2020
Messages: 200
Mentions "j'aime": 215
This trade definitely made up for one of the most underwhelming trade deadlines ever. Good move by the Red Wings IMO.
12 avr à 16 h 05
Rejoint: déc 2017
Messages: 3,581
Mentions "j'aime": 1,896
Yzerman has just announced himself on the world stage with this trade! DET will be back strong!!!
gretzkyghosts a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 16 h 06
Rejoint: jan 2016
Messages: 1,054
Mentions "j'aime": 122
The biggest surprise I've seen during this TDL.
12 avr à 16 h 07
Swedish Caps fan
Rejoint: jun 2019
Messages: 101
Mentions "j'aime": 40
*Crying in fetal position*
Very Angry
12 avr à 16 h 08
Rejoint: jan 2016
Messages: 1,054
Mentions "j'aime": 122
Quoting: rangersandislesfan
I don't understand this trade for Washington. Detroit wins IMO.

maybe their goal was Ovechkin + Backstrom + Mantha
12 avr à 16 h 11
Rejoint: avr 2018
Messages: 248
Mentions "j'aime": 131
This is a lite version of the Shanahan trade.
Paul Coffey for Brendan Shanahan
Keith Primeau Brian Glynn
1997 1st round pick

Although it looked like an overpayment from Detroit they ended up winning the Cup. Mantha as the big power forward certainly has the biggest upside of any of the players in this trade.
Laniccal et Capitalfail67 a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 16 h 11
Rejoint: mai 2015
Messages: 7,004
Mentions "j'aime": 2,506
I'm a big fan of Mantha, and he does add a slightly different style of play than Vrana, but the difference between them isn't that large. Certainly not a first and a second, even with a small cap dump. Well done Yzerman
Laniccal et gretzkyghosts a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 16 h 11
Rejoint: déc 2018
Messages: 324
Mentions "j'aime": 253
Not having to watch Mantha look like he's skating through quicksand every night just makes my day
gretzkyghosts et SweetRevenge19 a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 16 h 13
Rejoint: mai 2018
Messages: 23
Mentions "j'aime": 13
The Caps got a great player but gave away much too much for him. Never would have included Vrana, personally.
gretzkyghosts a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 16 h 17
Rejoint: sep 2019
Messages: 130
Mentions "j'aime": 55
Am I missing something? Watched a few red wings games and atleast in those Mantha played really badly. Was a defensive liability, looked uninterested etc. I was thinking that guy is going to get his contract bought out in a year or two. How is he worth this now? All off Vranas stats are better and although contract expiring its still RFA. Cant imagine it being much more than Manthas 5.7M/year atleast.
Laniccal et gretzkyghosts a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 16 h 18
Rejoint: fév 2021
Messages: 3,833
Mentions "j'aime": 1,186
Stevie Yzerman is the goat.

Brian MacLellan went from being an architect of a stanley cup winner to a below average ACGM on capfriendly.

He has an account on here and he used it for voting for the Capitals on this trade to make himself feel better.


I voted for the Detroit Red Wings.

No need to explain why.
12 avr à 16 h 22
Caps fan idk why
Rejoint: déc 2016
Messages: 9,454
Mentions "j'aime": 3,538
Quoting: mondo
I guess it wasn't enough for Yzerman to sweep Washington in the Stanley Cup finals.

HEY! WTF man .... didnt have to bring that up also....this was bad enough
12 avr à 16 h 22
Let's go Pens!
Rejoint: mar 2017
Messages: 1,728
Mentions "j'aime": 342
This is THE WORST TRADE for a team that I've seen in MANY YEARS. Washington gave up their heart and soul for a player which is not even at his best form and he's still a injury prone. Yzerman is a GREAT GM, indeed. But Caps GM being SO STUPID helped him A LOT.
12 avr à 16 h 25
depressed njd fan
Rejoint: jui 2020
Messages: 369
Mentions "j'aime": 311
my only guess as to why this trade was made is to make room to sign ovi

but....that still doesn't explain why they traded a first???
12 avr à 16 h 32
Rejoint: oct 2020
Messages: 5,450
Mentions "j'aime": 4,900
Holy cow, Steve Yzerman is a genius, I’m trading you Suzuki, Romanov, Kk, Caufield, Primeau and all our picks to get his rights so he can be our GM
12 avr à 16 h 47
a Jerk
Rejoint: fév 2018
Messages: 596
Mentions "j'aime": 145
Steve Yzerman! Detroit wins!
12 avr à 17 h 00
Rejoint: fév 2016
Messages: 1,135
Mentions "j'aime": 193
Mantha is the better player in this deal and makes WASH a better team right now. Vrana is a good player as well. Panik was a camp dump. I'm only struggling to understand why both a 1st and 2nd got included. Seems like one or the other for a fair deal. Not both.
RawDeal a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 17 h 01
Rejoint: jun 2018
Messages: 3,311
Mentions "j'aime": 1,736
Mantha's contract length gives him extra value. That's the only answer I have for Washington not being crazy
RawDeal a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 17 h 30
Watches no games
Rejoint: jui 2017
Messages: 3,194
Mentions "j'aime": 939
Vrana is a really good player, but I have to say Mantha is even better. Detroit gets a bunch of pieces, but I do think Washington walks away with the best player. As interesting it is to see Vrana with more playing time, you can't forget Mantha gets the better teammates where he's going. I think a lot of people saying Detroit won this are going to change their mind as Mantha looks great in with the Caps. I think reality is in between that, as this benefits both teams, and that we saw a good, unexpected hockey trade today.
RawDeal a aimé ceci.
12 avr à 17 h 39
Rejoint: jan 2019
Messages: 158
Mentions "j'aime": 147
Okay now that is a terrible trade for WSH to make imo. Does Mantha move the needle that much that it justified a 1st plus a solid middle six NHLer in Vrana? Doesn't feel like it to me..
12 avr à 18 h 06
addicted to pain
Rejoint: mai 2018
Messages: 5,463
Mentions "j'aime": 3,342
Someone call the cops cause the Wings just robbed the Capitals.
oneX et A_Habs_fan a aimé ceci.
To create a post please Login or S'inscrire
Soumettre les modifications du sondage