I don’t think Rittich is appreciably better than Reimer, especially that much better that a 2nd is required. Probably better off rolling with Raz Reims and Ned.

I’m not opposed to Staal as depth, but you’re not trading a roster forward, especially not a key PK and energy guy. Draft pick or mid level prospect only for Staal.

I think the Sabres can get more for Staal from another team

flames accept

That’s a Staal trade Buffalo would actually take.

He's got 10 points in 30 games. McGinn is outscoring him, makes less and is capable of playing on the top line. This is a DRASTIC overpay.

Staal needs to be for a mid draft pick. A 3rd at most. Otherwise, it hurts the team too much to make sense.

Rittich is also just not an upgrade on Nedeljkovic.