Not a chance Carolina does this. And don't even get me going on that Nashville trade. It's extremely terrible

Habs would need to add a roster player to clear cap but they take this deal

I'd agree that Mantha is underperforming and some WIngs fans overvalue him but if that's the return we just won't trade him.

If Wings were smart, they'd retain half his salary. That would up his value to a 1st round pick plus. Then again, im asking the Wings to be smart!

Ok. Love the reasoning.

Wings pass on every single deal except stl

what would colorado need to trade to get mantha with your value of him?

Preds don't trade Saros for a 4th

They'll have options. I didn't want to add Byron to this deal because every other fantasy team drawn up has Byron in this deal

So the Preds lose Ingram for nothing then in expansion. Askarov-Ingram is their future. That aint good asset management. Goalies dont hold much value

MTL would have to add some cap otherwise they can't do it.
Maybe Mysak, Tuch, Byron (Cap purposes) Kulak and a 2nd rounder or a 2021 1st but top 10 protected

Niederreiter is a top 6 forward who is one of their best top 6 forwards and Bean is a really good contract. Now that I think about it they might be open to trading Nied for a 2nd to resign a lot of their team, but I doubt hey want Bean in the deal. And as for the Nashville trade Saros has to be their starter for like the next 4 year before Askarov is ready, and what team is trading their starter for a 4th anyway?

If Mantha is traded, he wont get much. He'll age out of the rebuild.

Well this nonsense.

Its an expansion deal. Any goalie can be traded for magic beans at any time outside of Vasi and Helle.

Look up

Neither is trading Saros for a 4th...

If NSH trades Saros, it will be for a much better deal than this.

I also think some of the emerging goalies this year will be more enticing than Ingram given his unfortunate current circumstances.

So we trade Mantha for peanuts because a Hab fan wants him? Why does Detroit want to trade him at all, let alone when he isn't at 100%? Seems like poor asset management. Just because Mysak is your #2 ranked prospect per Pronman doesn't mean too much, we already have Zadina, Raymond, Berggren, etc. as winger prospects.

That Ottawa trade is bad return for Rasmussen. We have a good prospect in Pez and can go UFA shopping if Bernier doesn't return.

I agree and it's probably why Canadiens fan's should try to fix the Wing's!

Retain $2.85M for the next 3 years. Yeah ok!

Yeah I don't like the thought of giving up Nino and Beaner for just two 2nds. Not much of a return for two key pieces.

Yeah because no player has won their 1st cup after the age of 30.

You forgot the retention so its trade Mantha for peanuts and retain half of his salary.

Ingram as not showed that he can be an NHL goalie so why would seattle take him over players that could get exposed like Kunin or Sissons or Jarnkrok.

As a Wings fan it doesn't make much sense to me either. Saros for a 4th isn't going to happen.