Goaltending is weak but that offence is wild

You forgot PK Suban and D. from NJD. Both would be on the team in my opinion. And PK Subban can play either the LHD or RHD.

I did not forget Subban lol. Left him out intentionally, as he's worse than all six dmen above

Lol. The goaltending wouldn’t even be bad for an all-star team. I would probably start Crawford though. The better play-off goalie, when it counts.

I put him above Kempny easily. And Kulikov > Kempny. And Subban above Savard and Gardiner and Dillon too

Justin Braun is better than all 3 too.

Maybe 2016 Subban.

Justin Braun is better than all 3 right now and definitely in the past.

Sure, but he plays RD

Umm, yeah varma was pretty bad in the playoffs and is sheltered in a good defence and crow is just good. I didn’t mean they’re bad but they’re definitely not all star lol

Ya, I get it!! Crawford is an all-star goalie though..lol. But ya, I guess it isn’t great comparatively.

Crawford’s name is respected and super highly valued as he’s a 2 time champ(I can’t remember if he was with them for the first cup but My guess says no - although his name may be on the cup). But he is no longer all star. He’s still good - but he’ll need to be very good this year in New Jersey, which isn’t impossible, to get that all star type title again. He hasn’t been bad but he definitely doesn’t come up when I think of all stars in the league or the best goalies in the league currently (his resume doesn’t = his value, his play does for the most part but he’s still good).

Crawford had made all star games. He Is an all star goalie. And won SC’s. Is a Stanley cup winning goalie. Both those statements are facts!!

And Crawford was the starting goalie for both of chicago’s SC.

You didn’t listen to anything I said. That’s his resume. Just because Brodeur is the top 3 goalie all time doesn’t mean he’s good right now. Brodeur wasn’t good in St. Louis - THATS because his resume doesn’t mean you’re good forever. You’re performance says if you’re good or not or elite or amazing etc. Just because binnington won a cup doesn’t mean he was amazing or all star esc last year - because he struggled a lot. Doesn’t mean he’s bad.

Crow LITERALLY wasn’t the all star goalie for the central division lol if that’s you’re argument as well. Just because you’re good In the past doesn’t mean you’re good now.

Is Crawford a goalie well remember and talk about being on the greatest goalies of the decade when Chicago was winning cups - probably. But he’s not a all star goalie currently, was he before/ when he retires? Yes.

Once again - resume doesn’t mean you’re amazing currently. Just like skinner - bad currently, not bad before. Just because skinner used to be good doesn’t mean he is.

I completely listen and read everything you write. I just disagree.

I think Crawford is a All-Star goalie. He’s a
Proven all-star goalie. He has done it in the past, he can do it again. Just like people say he’s a 20 goal scorer. No he’s not if he never has. If he has, then yes, he’s a 20 goal scorer. For his whole career!! You’ve done it once, you’ve proven it. You can repeat that performance, it’s not potential anymore.