That is very generous to Anaheim

Comtois in my eyes will be as good as Cirelli. And getting a top 4D and a top 6F on excellent contracts

Comtois will be around Cirelli’s range once he reaches nhl level.
Sergachev is a great upgrade from Manson
Killorn is a downgrade from Rakell ( contract and point wise )

This is a weird trade because if we were planning on contending this year this would be a great trade. But considering we’re in a limbo situation of we don’t where we are I’d just say we should pass right now. However if Murray brings in a backup like Anderson or Howard and wants to contend, I’d pull the trigger on this and go for it.

But Sergachev and Cirelli are very young so they can be part of your contending team for a long time

That’s why I like it but then they want mula

You have a ton of expiring cap hha

Very true. In all seriousness I’d pull the trigger on this one. However!!! I would swap Comtois for Milano and throw in a 3rd

Honestly the value looks fine but I'm not really sure why the Ducks do it. Sergachev is a great player but he's not an upgrade on Fowler or Lindholm so unless we trade one of them I don't see why we would want him. Cirelli is the big get here but we have Steel who is a year younger and may be able to be what Cirelli is, though this still is the biggest immediate update. that upgrade is countered a bit by downgrading on wing and then we have a hole in D corp for a PKing Dman. It just doesn't seem to make a whole lot of sense to me as a Ducks fan from a roster structure stand point.

Sergachev can play both sides and is a huge upgrade on Manson. He’s a legit #2 Dman right now and I think he’s better than Fowler. As for Killorn he’s a 50pt winger and Cirelli is a 50pt elite 2 way centre

I honestly don't watch enough Tampa games to really argue the point but looking at the numbers to me it looks like Serg is sheltered in Tampa. Something the Ducks would struggle to do. He only had 34 pts last year getting PP time with the 5th best PP in the league. Got less PK time per game than Luke Schenn. Serg had the 4th best SAT % and the most Offensive zone starts of any D who played at least 30 games for Tampa. His PPG is about equal to Fowler who had similar numbers on a much worse team. As for the other 2 that is fair but I would still consider Killorn a downgrade on wing. He doesn't have the upside that Rakell has and its not like Rakell is bad defensively. Like I said Cirelli is the big get but the other pieces don't really make sense to me. Maybe just leave it at Cirelli and Killorn for Rakell and Steel?