Who even rates kreider?

Demelo, Pelech, Lindlom and Tanev arent overrated.

Pelech 😂

well at least he's till top line caliber on this list

Dear Joe Sakic,

If you're most overrated player is Joonas Donskoi, I think you're doing something right.

Most of these players are not overrated. Most of these players are bashed on a regular basis.

McNabb? You lost me.

I think dougie Hamilton should 100% be carolina’s representative. Theres doofuses on here thinking hes a top 3 d man in the league.

Yes they are. Demelo is a decent defenceman, a 4th/5th defenceman I would say, but people do tend to overrate him. Pelech is overrated by Islanders fans. Again a 4th/5th defenceman in my eyes but is treated like a top pairing guy sometimes. Tanev is overrated 100%, he looked like a 4th liner at points last year. Lindblom is just on here because most Flyers players aren't really overrated. I mean you could maybe say JVR but Ghost has lost his reputation obviously and basically everyone else lives up to expectations.

I was actually going to put Lemeiux but he didn't show up for some reason, I think it is because he is still an RFA.

Bottom pairing guy who is good in his own end imo, but he doesn't belong in the top 4

I was actually going to put Lemeiux but he didn't show up for some reason, I think it is because he is still an RFA.

A 4th/5th defenceman in my eyes but is treated like a top pairing guy sometimes.

where he plays has nothing to do with being overrated. He excels in his role and he forms a solid 1st pairing with Pulock. If anything he doesnt get any credit, usually Pulock gets it

Who is overrating Bogosian? rofl

Because he is a top 3 dman lol

Rather unfair to young Jack who was 19 last season

Or do you mean in general maybe?

Hm

Duchene is not overrated if anything he’s underrated

but I was told Bogosian is the next scott stevens...? are you sure he's overrated?

Mostly leaf fans. Some think he is still a solid top 4 defenceman without Hedman by his side

no hes not

hes overrated

Nah I just see his value overhyped a bit. I think he has a lot to prove still and he needs to build up some strength. He just seems like such a small guy out there who can't really do much.

Damn, guess I should have put him on here lol.

hall should be buffalos, laine should be wpgs, kassian for edm