Quoting: Claesson4Norris
I've had this debate so many times, and I just can't convince myself not to put him there. Over 1200 games, 300 goals, nearly 800 points, and he was otherworldly in the playoffs. I think he's probably a fringe case, but I think the legend of Justin Williams the playoff performer gets him in. 3 cups, 160 games, 100 points, and a Conn Smythe.
He's probably going to wait around for a long time, but he should be in the HOF in my opinion.
What about Eric Staal, Rick Nash, Jeff Carter, Mike Richards, Simon Gagne, Gaborik, Koivu, Gionta, Claude Lemieux (he has a smythe), Turgeon, Mogilny, Tkachuk, Naslund, Hejduk, Bertuzzi, Prospal, Satan, Sharp, B. Richards, Tanguay, Voracek