Quoting: Wpgman
Severson can play with Morrissey on the first line. Pionk can't. That is the difference.
Quoting: Windjammer
Not if you want a good top pairing he can't. Severson is a decent second pair guy with limited offense. So, not an upgrade.
The problem I see with this trade and most defense addition ideas for the Jets in general is if you trade Pionk for a better RHD to pair with Morrissey like is done here for Severson then DeMelo slides down to the 2nd pair but then the Jets don't have a quality LHD like a H.Lindholm to make DeMelo a passable 2nd pair RHD.
In other threads I've seen it's make a big trade like one of the young wingers for a Pulock for example and put Pulock on the 2nd pairing to have two strong pairings but then Pionk is moving up to the top pairing and he and Morrissey are just too small to be paired together which is also why I don't see Morrissey-DeMelo as a number one D pair, DeMelo is also too slow imo.
So no matter what I think this team is short two top 4 dmen and at the very least they need one more true top 4 dman cause as of right now if one of Morrissey or Pionk gets injured for any extended period of time the season is gonna go south in a hurry.
I think a 2nd pair of Forbort-Pionk will be fine but if Pionk gets hurt then what, I think he can compliment Pionk's game but Forbort isn't carrying a D pairing.
As for the two young guys Heinola and Samberg I just don't know if either should be counted on to log top 4 minutes already and as good as Heinola looked in his 8 games I really worry how he'll make out in playoff hockey.
The remaining dmen of Beaulieu, Poolman, Sbisa in any configuration will make a solid 3rd pair and I'd have faith in them moving into the top 4 in a pinch for a game or two but none of them would be long term options if anyone is out long term. I think Niku is done with the organization, even though I like him I just don't see him as a factor, hope he lands on his feet with some team that'll give him a chance.
With all that said the Jets have 7 dmen under contract, one RFA dman to sign in Niku but like I said I think he's not coming back and they have two prospects that seem like they both have a good chance to make the team but with 7 dmen under contract where do they fit, I highly doubt that Forbort or Sbisa signed with the Jets to be veteran dmen on the Manitoba Moose.
As much as I'd like to see another top 4 dman brought in or Hamonic signed for a year unless there's a big trade I wonder if they're not done tinkering with this
D core.