I don't think the Rangers should trade Lemieux especially when he's the only one on the team that will stand up to Tom Wilson.

Also make this trade for next season...

I get that but I think he is too undisciplined. His analytics are not very good either.

It doesn't really matter. Every team should have a player like Lemieux, even in today's game. I wouldn't trade him unless you have a replacement. Maybe Matt Martin?

I agree with this. Canes need one of these guys haha

But it does matter. I think Lemeiux as a player is fine and he does bring some value like you are saying but to me he is replaceable. If the Rangers can move him for something of greater value I would do it. McNabb is a guy who has played over 19 minutes a night over the past 3 years, plays a physical game, blocks shots, and is an affordable LHD until the young kids are ready. As good as Miller projects to be it is unrealistic to expect him to step right in and play top 4 minutes.

Brayden McNabb is one of those dudes who I always forget exists

Isn't that what you want in a defender, a guy who doesn't stand out. Means no mistakes are being made.

Tim Murray traded both of them

Lemieux and Reaves on the same team, nah,

Get you a guy that can also like... play hockey.

I agree on all points just think it should be georgiev as you can't keep lehner and you can bridge georgiev for relatively cheap until fleury expires, that and lemieux is cheaper and more of a need for us

Would Carolina move either Bean or Fleury for him?

They wouldn't move bean and we wouldn't accept fleury

Yeah we would definitely move Bean as hes the most likely to get taken in the expansion draft.

rangers aren't moving him

You are probably right. He is Quinns type of guy.

Hes also just too valuable and unique as a bottom 6 guy. Just needs to get better defensively. If you could have a 4th line plug or Lemieux for a few more dollars, my guess is most teams would rather have Lemieux. Just brings more of an edge to the lineup

I dont see his value as irreplaceable. He does have a unique skill set that you want in a bottom 6 forward but when I watch him I see a guy who is too undisciplined and decisions he makes are detrimental to the rangers. I dont thi k he will ever be more of a 4th liner and if you can get a quality player for him then I would do it.