these are all over the place...how can you go from panarin, zibby, and kakko to barzal, beauvillier, and dobson? the values are so different from one trade to the next.

I would rather keep what I would have in package going from Toronto and not do that for Connor McDavid. I would rather keep the depth.

Well what one do you think is the best. It's a bit subjective

But what trade is the best do you think?

I like the Carolina deal the best. Aho and Svechnikov

They are all over the best so Im not really sure which is the best one..

Vancouver one damn. Pettey and Hughes

Easy reject

Edit: I know this isn't meant to be serious

Didn’t need to include a C in each deal. Oilers would still have leon and nuge for top six a very solid goalie and winger plus picks is more direction I’d look at.

Sabres trade should just be 2020 1st and eichel and even then buffalo would reject

The only deal remotely close is the NYR deal.
CAR is almost close too.

Vancouver offer is the best one imo. You get back a top line point per game C, and a dynamic point producing 1st pair LD on top of a 1st and a decent goalie prospect. Pretty nice

I’m only interested in the Carolina and Vancouver trades at best

I’d still rather keep McDavid

Agree and also a total overpay if you include both Pettersson and Hughes. A more realistic trade would be something like Pettersson, Podokolzin, and 2 firsts.

yeah I never said Vancouver would do it lol, just that it's the best return on here.

That's what I thought you said. Didn't mean to imply any different.

TBL TOR VAN are overpays same with NYR

you could argue the CAR one, i still think EDM wins that one

Islanders is a tricky one

NJ deal no for Oilers

FLA and BUFF are very similar deals but id say no if i was EDM

all these teams want to contend, so by trading these parts, they are losing their chance to contend . I would reccommened trading for picks and prospects

no way does trading McDavid net any of these returns... he's a great player, but is he worth that much more than the return... out of each trade i would put the top player from each team: Matthews, Pettersson, Eichel, Aho, J Hughes, Panarin, Kucherov, Barzal and Barkov... and then add ONE OF a 1st round pick or a top prospect. anything more than that is paying too much