Quoting: CD282
IMO Benning has more value than Andersson and a late round pick swap is nowhere near the difference.
But it's interesting that you should compare Andersson to Benson (who also has less value than Benning). Both played in the AHL as 20 and 21-year-olds, so there is some basis to compare:
At 20
TB: 68, 15-51-66 +21 (0.97 P/GP)
LA: 36, 6-14-20 -24 (0.56 P/GP)
At 21
TB: 47, 9-27-36 -10 (0.77 P/GP)
LA: 13, 4-1-5 -9 (0.38 P/GP)
Overall career boxcars in the AHL
TB: 120, 24-81-105 +10 (0.88 P/GP)
LA: 74, 15-24-39 -33 (0.53 P/GP)
Other than being a center, I don't think there's much basis for thinking Andersson is a better prospect than Tyler Benson. Fifteen games in the SHL (at 0.80 P/GP) isn't enough to erase the years of mediocre play on the part of the NYR prospect. It's a glimmer of hope, nothing more.
oh nice you like statistics
I compared age*...
But again it's pretty tough to compare someone like Benson vs. Lias. Lias had a foot injury for most of this year. and Hartford last year was the worst AHL team in the league (they cleaned out their entire staff after last year) while Bakersfield ran away with the division last year.
Looking at the NHLe numbers and the primary points to try and isolate individual contributions from team quality: (NHL translations for reference:
https://twitter.com/mannyelk/status/1014216462695878658 )
DY + 1: Benson (WHL) 1.09 P1/GP = 0.17 NHLe P1/GP
DY + 1: Andersson (SHL) 0.50 P1/GP = 0.32 NHLe P1/GP
DY + 1: Andersson (AHL) 0.28 P1/GP = 0.12 NHLe P1/GP
D + 2: Benson (WHL) 0.95 P1/GP = 0.15 NHLe P1/GP
D + 2: Andersson (AHL) 0.39 P1/GP = 0.17 NHLe P1/GP
D + 2: Andersson (NHL) 0.10 P1/GP = 0.10 NHLe P1/GP
D + 3: Benson (AHL) 0.71 P1/GP = 0.30 NHLe P1/GP
D + 3: Andersson (AHL) 0.38 P1/GP = 0.16 NHLe P1/GP
D + 3: Andersson (SHL) 0.60 P1/GP = 0.38 NHLe P1/GP
D+ 4: Benson (AHL) .55 P1/GP = 0.23 NHLe P1/GP
The trade wasn't Lias for Benson so I'm not sure why you're forcing the comparison, when the entire point was just to show age. But Lias is a defensive C, Benson is a pass heavy winger. The fact that their point production when you control for context is close doesn't really make Benson look far superior at all...