From an outsider, valu looks pretty fair here.

No. Chicago isn’t getting Eichel for that package. Sorry

Really, based off of what ive seen from sabre fans, is that theyre not trading eichel unless you give them your entire first line, your best prospects and 3 1sts...

I proposed something like this a while back but Chicago would need a RHD back as well so give them Montour and they can add another piece. Its definitely fair

No way you would get Brodin in this trade. Not even close

How about that package for Austin Matthews? Oh, he’s not available and it would take more than that to acquire him? That’s odd.

Well this is a not bad offer, but still no. I would probably even prefer to add some parts from Buffalo to get DeBrincat, not Saad.

Facts, Replace Saad with DBC and I like it

To acquire Matthews, I’d ask for
Dach
1st (2020)
Boqvist
Nylander
Debrincat

Eichel>Mathews

I think that's too much for Eichel, so probably a fair trade

Your probably missing one good piece in this trade for eichel.

Not that it wouldnt happen but to be fair it's about one piece too short.

You have a center replacement for eichel in dach although dach probably wont amount to eichel. You have a top 10 pick. Saad is not valuable to the sabres in this scenario cause his age doesn't fit their new window. And beaudin is a good piece. So I would say your one 1st away whether that's a prospect or 1st but I dont know if 2021 would do it since you guys would be a playoff team for sure with eich

Saad is easily flipped at the TDL for a 1st if thats what BUF wants to do. Or they can keep him, he's only 27

Yeah they can flip him but that's more work for the gm and that's dependent on playing solid throughout the year with no centers and not getting hurt. So a bit risky imo.

I mean it looks fair but Sabres fans tend to overvalue Eichel (which I guess is fair, franchise centres don't come around very often)