Just so I understand clearly, one year of Freddy before he is a UFA is worth a 1st and Jarry under team control as an RFA is worth a 2nd and two worthless pieces?

Bracco and Kerfoot are worthless to Pittsburgh other teams it would be different.

Again with people overrating Jarry! After the first 18 games he has had a 0.901sv%. Andersen has been good his entire career until December.
please explain how the second and Kerfoot are useless

Bracco had 4 goals this year in the AHL. Kerfoot is signed for term at 3.5 million and didn't break double digit goals on one of the best offensive team in the league

Was more explaining an RFA Jarry has more value than a UFA Freddy, but interpret however you feel. Kerfoot's contract for his production kills his trade value and he would be a fourth liner in Pittsburgh. At least you agree Bracco is worthless

Lehner didn't even get a 1st and here's the difference between them...

Freddy - GP 52 GAA 2.85 SV% .909 GSAA -0.35 HDGSAA -3.01
Lehner - GP 36 GAA 2.89 SV% .920 GSAA +12.72 HDGSAA +0.59

BUT. I do understand the questions around Jarry. it's not like he has a ton of ice time. I'm always cautious around new goalies. It's entirely possible other teams just need time to figure out their weaknesses. The 2nd half of his season was quite a bit different than the 1st half.

Carolina pass. With a shot at Lehner, we still have no need to take on goalies you don't want. Especially for 1st round picks.

It's not all about points FFS. Kerfoot had a down year overall, but he's always been a defensive-center center with excellent shutdown abilities. Put him on a line with McCann & add someone like Fast or Nichuskin, you've got an excellent line.

Haha Jarry maybe at best gets a 2nd round pick. People need to stop this silly overvaluing goalie nonsense. Jarry played well for a few games but he’s 25 years old and has 62 nhl games played. At no point in those 62 games played was he a starting goalie. It’s completely possible that he’s an elite goalie but it’s also possible that he’s a career backup. With all the talented goalies going to FA why would a team give up a 2nd 2-3c and a prospect for a giant question mark in goal. Again it’s completely possible that Jarry is elite but 31 games isnt convincing me to give up that much for him. I would trade those for assets and sign RL if that’s what Jarry costs

I wouldn’t necessarily call kerfoot worthless due to the fact that he’d keep Jared McCann on the wing making Pittsburgh deeper as a result. I do agree that I messed up the Freddy trade though and plan on changing it.



But if there’s a CBO nobody probably gets a shot a Lehner because I’d expect them to CBO Fleury and extend Lehner.

McCann shouldn't play wing, he said himself he never played there before this year. Kerfoot is a very low end 3C, would rather just have McCann there

If Jarry is so overrated why go through all the trouble of moving Anderson and picking up Jarry. Canes easily pass

Bigger problem was Freddy getting a 1st in this ACGM but you ignore that......

If Kerfoot was such a defensive specialist TOR would probably want to keep him.... and even then his contract is not that great all things considered.

I mean he cost them a first but that's not as unrealistic as getting that haul for a backup goalie that hasn't proven he can be a starter. Jarry had a really solid 18 game span but hes at most worth a 2nd. FA could get a late 1st its unlikely but its possible. its impossible for the penguins to get a 2nd 2-3c and a prospect for Jarry. hes 25 Jarry isn't that young.

Well, I think he gets a package much like the one here.

Freddy is better than Jarry. Not this season, but considering Freddy's record, he's better. I don't think it is farfetched to think he gets a 1st. Maybe him and a second for a first.

K if Jarry was to come to the leafs I believe it starts with Kapenan.

Who is better is different than who has more value. Have to take age and contract status into account

I realize that. But Freddy's contract is not overpaid, so he's still worth a bit as a rental. Jarry is worth a fair amount too, I'd say both of them are worth the same.

Jarry or FA. if Jarry could get this type of return than the Devils should trade blackwood for a 1st pick and a high end prospect. sad truth is that goalies don't have this type of value... Jarry hasn't shown he could play an entire season and nobody knows how good he is in playoffs. he could be a choke artist.... if the leafs really need a goalie to win now why risk FA for a complete unknown just to save a few $$$. I would just go all in for Gibson at this point

When did I trade for Jarry? please show me. Another troll here. Just mentioning how overrated Jarry is on this site.

Not you as in you personally but you as in the idea of, if hes overrated why trade for him

cause you don't have a goalie. He is young to so I assume that's why people trade for him.
I don't trade for Jarry. I try to tell everyone that he isn't as good as people say

Toronto has 2 goalies though, unless Andersen is toast