Take Mantha off and shift Point to RW and include JT.

I wanted to, but I’d either be ripped on a leaf bias, and Point is normally a C

chabot

Would’ve, but LD is STACKED in the Atlantic. He hasn’t had a better career than any of these guys and all are a bit better. No doubt he creeps into this list over he next 2-3 years

I just don't see why Mantha would deserve to be mentioned. Barkov as well should be there. Tkachuk will be a great player no doubt, but he's not deserving to be included yet either.

It’s crazy that Marner makes more than Eichel.

Chabot is a better overall defender than Reilly. He doesn't put up the offensive numbers like Reilly but he is a stronger defensive player by a significant margin.

Instead of JT, how about Barkov?

Oh stop. Marner is almost as good as Eichel.

Brady Tkachuk generates more offense, specifically high danger offense better than most players in the league, and he does it with no help. He's definitely deserving of being on there

Then you won't have any redwings, but yes, JT and Barkov and Chabot deserve consideration.

Both. Take out Tkachuk and Mantha.

Who cares? They don't deserve any players on the team.

Ever heard of Brad Marchand? You know the LW with #63 that plays 11 times a year against your team

Don't be one of those clowns that thinks unless we love the player as much as you that we think he's crap. He's awesome and is going to be terrific. However, right now there are better players than him. In 2 seasons, it will be a different story.

chabot should be there instead of krug, barkov marchand and jt should be there instead of nylander mantha and brady, stamkos is overrated

and makes 800k more lol, huuuuuuuuge difference

You are probably right, I forgot about Marchand. Nylander I think by next season will move past Stamkos who you are right is overrated. I think instead of Krug coming off though it should be Ekblad. I'd likely take Weber off as well in favour of Dahlin.

Yes, I agree, but I thought that was part of the criteria.

I don't actually know? Maybe, if so than I think I'd include Larkin over Mantha anyways.

Ya, Larkin is better. But if a redwing doesn't need to be on, then they shouldn't, because the redwings, well, we all know the redwings.

I will say though, this squad would dummy both western conferences and I am not sure the Metro would keep up over a long stretch. The Pacific is garbage in comparison to this depth. Really though if you just combined TO, Boston and Tampa, the team is unreal.

in a few years probably, no chance he makes this team today

Detroit needs one guy lol

Just a salty leafs fan lolol. Guy put Matthews on the first line and NYLANDER over Brady