Of all the trades on here this makes the most sense. BUF is going to want a top line young piece back.

I'd be okay with this but I don't really like if for Buffalo.

But I thought Marner is carried by Tavares?????

hahahahahaha this is soooooo bad for BUF

If Eichel requests a trade out of Buffalo what can you do?

nothing says toronto more than having 3 $10,00,000+ centers while icing dermott as your top pair rd.

Trade him for the fair value maybe

Whose gonna do that? Bruins would have to give up Pasternak plus for fair value...

Never said Bruins (and it's not like 88 will be moved). And you can find a team wanting Eichel

There will be 10 to 20 trade proposals for Eichel. 8 to 18 are better than this. This trade leaves the Sabres with no centers and no assets to get one. Terrible offer. Or they just keep him until the last year of his deal. Nice consolation prize. If there isn't am overpay, he isn't traded. End of story.

No. You clearly haven't looked at many Eichel trades. There have been at least 50 better efforts and many if those were very bad. This trade leaves Buffalo with no centers and no assets to get one after this trade. He goes to Montreal before Toronto.

Okay what offer is better than this? Whose gonna give up one of their star players plus a high end prospect for Eichel? Nashville?

Every team wants Eichel. But I don't think any will give a better deal than this... Maybe Columbus if they want PLD + some picks?

You forgot Bracco.

The one you said was a solid offer was 2 years of Forsburg, a 6M 3rd line C cap dump, Fabbro and 2 1sts. I'd say that was a worse offer

and Johnsson.

Montreal, Nashville, Ottawa (though Melnyk kills it), pretty much anyone willing to deal a legit 2C and high-end futures as this deal is baaaad. If this is the only offer Buffalo still says no even if Eichel has a warrant for his arrest in NY. That's how bad it is.

Marner doesn't do anything to make Buffalo better short term or long.

Still better than your crap offer which makes zero sense for Buffalo. One of the worst most out of touch deals I've seen. And now you're stalking me? Lol, getting desperate to defend your terrible trade offer.

Just wanted to see what you thought was a fair deal. Obviously you like long term cap dumps like Jeff Skinner. Toronto doesn't have any of those deals...

Marner's much better than anything you get in that deal.

What's Montreal gonna give you Domi? Ottawa gives you Tierney?

With a mediocre to poor defense.

I haven't seen any with a young elite talent like this but maybe I haven't seen them all.