Hello. This is a new challenge that I am doing that is suppose to help me in nhl 20. I am going to show my player ratings for every team. I want to see what other people think so I can have the most perfect rating in nhl 20. That way nhl 20 for me can be very realistic. This also helps me learn more about each team. If you want to join you can. My ratings are probably all wrong so I want to learn. Remember, this is for fun and we may have a different view on player ratings. Especially prospects, Here are my devils player ratings
Matthew Barzal - 88 overall, med elite
Ryan Pulock - 87 overall, high top 4
Anders Lee - 85 overall
Semyon Varlamov - 85 overall
Brock Nelson - 85 overall
Josh Bailey - 84 overall
Jordan Eberle - 84 overall
Jean Gabriel Pageau - 84 overall
Ilya Sorokin - 84 overall, low elite
Adam Pelech - 83 overall, med top 4
Nick Leddy - 83 overall
Devon Toews - 83 overall, med top 4
Anthony Beauvilleur - 82 overall, med top 6
Scott Mayfield - 81 overall, med top 6
Casey Cizikas - 81 overall
Cal clutterback - 80 overall
Noah Dobson - 80 overall, high top 4
79 or lower (everybody else)
Otto Koivula - 79 overall, med top 6 (just missed)
Notable prospects
Simon Holmstrom - 65 overall, med top 6
Bode Wilde - 67 overall, med top 4
Kieffer Bellows - 74 overall, med top 6
Oliver Wahlstrom - 70 overall, med top 6
Blade Jenkins - 65 overall, low top 6
Félix Bibeau - 68 overall, low top 6
Legend
Potentials
Franchise - 92 - 96 overall - best players in the nhl
Elite - 87 - 91overall - first liners
top 6 - 83 - 86 overall - first/ second liners
top 9 - 80 - 82 overall - 3rd/ 4th liners
bottom 6 - 77 - 79 overall - 4th liners/ ahlers
I think you're a point too high on Pulock and a point too low on Pelech (whose defensive stats should be the reason why his rating is an 84). Maybe a point high on Sorokin (still unknown commodity but hopefully lives up to the hype). Beau also a point too low. Became a really good two way player this year under Trotz.
I'd drop Bailey and Leddy a point each, move Pelech up one (maybe two, but defense doesn't rate as highly on the game) and Koivula is more likely to be a top-9 guy, but otherwise looks good.