Eichel needs to be a candidate in my opinion. He’s the exact definition of the hart trophy.

I think your NYR jammies are showing...

It kinda is difficult to be in there when your team doesn't make the playoffs or isn't even close to it but he difinitely is the 4th choice here.

No man you haven't seen Fox and Panarin play. Also if my NYR colors were truly showing Carlson and Hart wouldn't be here

It's sad. Every option above has a better player on their team

Yup indeed. Why did Botterill trade ROR? Did he as for a trade?

Sucks man

Yes, the Sabres with ROR would be a very good team imho...but he asked for a trade, lost the love for hockey here.

Man that's tough for you. Is it true that the owners, the Pegulas don't know anything about hockey?

And what would be the first step in fixing the team? Getting a 2C for Skinner? Getting a G to help out Ullmark?

No man I get that and Eichel is a beast but the Sabres were not even close to the playoffs... I can't really put a player who plays on a team in that situation in the Hart conversation... sorry... and yes it was dumb that McDavid was there last year

What I think should happen and what will are 2 different things.
I agree with your 3 and the order on the Hart. However what will probably happen is Draisitl wins.
Norris agree with your 3 would probably have Carlson winning it.
Vezina - I got no issues with the 3 or winner
Calder - the top 3 are right, but I’ll take Makar.

Good list though!

Hughes is better at D than Makar and he has more point that Makar. Hughes wins that

For MacKinnon, the guy carried his team for a full month if I remember correctly without Rantanen and Landeskog... Draisaitl only had to play like 2 weeks and a half without 97. MacK wins there.

Josi wins the Norris because he singlehandedly carried the Preds this season. Without him they aren't even close to the playoffs

Mack
Drai
Pasta

Carl
Peitro
Josi

Helly
Rask
Big Ben

QH or Makar...

Honestly Makar is my Calder because look at those stats. 50 points in 57 games, and Hughes is 53 points in 67 games. Had Makar been healthy the whole season, he would've gotten 72 points, whereas Hughes would've only gotten 65. I think it's going to be a close race.

Tho Hughes is better at D and IMO is as good as Makar offensively... and is 2 years younger!

Surprised Rask isn't even a finalist. Looking at goalies who started at least 40 games.

1st in GAA
1st in SV%
2nd in SO

I should remove Bishop and replace him with Rask?

I think drai over panarin but I think he's top 3, but many players can make a case for the hart. Fox is no question top3 in calder. I wouldn't put him over makar or Hughes, but he's not as far off as some people think

Sorry those numbers put Tuukka just a wee-little-tiny-bitty behind Henry, John Davidson and Eddie Giacomin

For all of you who trust analytics:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/picking-2019-20-35930527

Its a breakdown of the Top 5 rookies this year based on their metrics

No, its entirely based on your opinion. My opinion is Rask should win the Vezina. On top of the stats, he lost on 2 games in regulation at home. He also only lost 8 games in regulation all season.

I wish the season wasnt stoped i was interested to see how far helly could drag the jets, if they made the playoffs and got rnd 2 or 3. Wasnt there a thing where he had votes for the hart