Rejoint: déc. 2017
Messages: 5,012
Mentions "j'aime": 3,523
This is a really tough question b/c some of the best regular season Goalies have been rather indifferent in the playoffs. Placing a lot of emphasis on playoff success, I'll go with the following:
1. Quick
2. Holtby
3. Lundqvist
4. Price
5. Rask
6. Bobrovsky
7. Fleury
8. Crawford
9. Luongo
10. Miller
Just Missed:
11. Bishop
12. Rinne
13. Schneider
14. Halak
15. C. Anderson
The toughest calls were Holtby over Lundqvist and Bob over Fleury. It's basically a toss-up in my opinion, but Holtby was pretty dominant during the Caps Cup run. Despite Henrik's amazing career playoff numbers, he never won the Cup. They each have one Vezina, I believe. Clearly, Lundqvist has had the better career overall.
Fleury has won 2 Cups with PIT in the last decade, but wasn't really the #1 for either run. He was outstanding w/ Vegas though. Bob has been arguably the best regular season Goalie of the last 10 years, despite negligible playoff success. His two Vezina Trophies def. give him the edge. Had Fleury been the #1 with PIT over Matt Murray or had Vegas won the Cup in 2018, I'd switch them up for sure.