Replace Holl with Liljegren

Leafs don't do it.

Its already an overpay lol



Leafs already don't do it.

What

Overpay for Manson and Kerfoot has more value to the Leafs than that.

Leafs don't do this trade as is. They aren't trading Holl weeks after extending him, they aren't trading Robertson, a 1 and a 2 included? The coat is going to be Liljegren+. Probably Kappy. That's a price they should be willing to pay.

Probably not, it is an overpay but the point is without a replacement there is almost no interest in ANA moving him

There is no way that Leafs trade Robertson as he is absolutely lighting up the OHL this year and may be arriving to Leafs much sooner than expected.

Im hunting Manson from times when he really seem to be No.2 D with shutdown upside but this is blatant overpay for the state hes playing at the moment......

They don't have much of a choice if they want Manson, Because that trash doesn't get him. Without Liljegren heading to Anaheim Manson wont be a Leaf.

Overpay for Manson, That package is pure garbage. And Bob murray would block Dubas number if that was his offer for Manson.

I think you are delusional, Seriously. Robertson is one of the best prospects in the league this year. Holl is basically a Manson with far less experience and a d prospect and a first and a second. The ducks president would fire the gm if he found out he turned that package down and with all that being said I don't see the leafs moving Robertson or the first let alone both so clearly there is no deal to be done with a package like this

LMAO does manson have beer flavored nipples HAHAHA like dudes maybe johnsson and a 3rd THATS IT. quit these BS trades

?

A first, a cheaper defenseman who has been nearly as good this year, an a but not blue chip prospect and a good B prospect? How on earth is that garbage?

I'm not convinced Manson is worth much more than a first...

This trade has significantly more value than Liljegren...

Bottom line is Anaheim doesn't need more wingers, Holl with less experience then Manson and the exact same age isn't going to cut it. If Murray deals Manson he'll want a similar return for Manson RD and sorry Holl isn't it. Dude sorry you're not getting Manson for his. First off he's not even being shopped. Reportedly the Leafs have strong interest in him. Murray hasn't made him available. Down season or not Murray loves the guy and he's going to cost a pretty penny. This does nothing for the Ducks sorry but that's a pure fact. Murray would easily turn this down he doesn't have to move Manson anytime soon.

A cheaper RD same age with less NHL experience then Manson, Why would Murray be interested in that he needs a major shakeup at RD Manson is by far his best RD and Holl is nowhere near enough or close enough to what Bob Murray would want a RD for Manson that is a major downgrade. Yeah Manson is having a terrible season by his own standards. But so is then entire Anaheim team, Like i've stated numerous times before Manson isn't on the trade block and even Murray himself said that a team will absolutely have to blow him away with an offer to move Manson. And i'm sorry man this would not blow Murray away.

Sorry agree to disagree, Picks aren't that great Holl less value then Manson don't really care who Robertson is. This return isn't getting you Manson. Pretty sure at least one of Andreas Johnsson or Kasperi Kapanen would need to be added to peak Murray's interest.

Manson is nowhere near worth that.

Robertson is a better prospect than Liljegren....

If true, Then why not move Liljegren over Robertson?

That's what we're saying this is an overpayment.

Lololol "don't really care who Robertson is" man if you had any idea of value of prospects you would know Robertson is going to be far better kapanen or johnsson. For a team like the ducks they want prospects, not ready players due to the age of their team.

No one in this thread has said Manson is being shopped. The consensus is that it's a large overpayment. Manson is worth a defense prospect and a first or a roster player prospect and a second simple as that. Just because he is not being shopped doesn't mean his value is actually higher.