Vancouver

Both, those type of players normally dont get dealt until later in their careers. at this point, i believe both teams consider them untouchable

Easily Vancouver

VAncouver by a mile

Both

Both, but Vancouver easily hangs up the phone

Vancouver because QH is the team's number 1 dman and the team doesn't need a center as much.

NJ because they still needs a top-line forward.

I love the idea of calling Jack or Quinn: " Hey, we just traded for your brother, ... but ... you gotta pack your bags now. ............Yeah we traded him for you. Can he have your old number? That way the fans don't have to change jerseys."

if the teams needed the other players position and its a one for one, maybe...but not with VAN adding its 1st...

why does Van give up a first and only get a second back?

Quinn - neck and neck in the calder voting
Jack - on pace for the worst season by a first overall pick ever.

i wouldn't even do 1 for 1

Have you watched/seen Jack play at all this year?? The guy is almost always the most skilled player on the ice.

The thing with him is that he's still just a child and probably should not be in the NHL for another 1-2 years. (Compared to Matthews, McDavid, etc. who were grown man at 18 years old). And people knew this coming into the season but I guess NJD really wanted to get him into the lineup.

But yes, Quinn is a stud and meets VAN organizational needs.

That said, in terms of value around the league, a #1 center is more valuable than a #1 Defense.