I dont really want to give up lily but that Detroit trade is pure garbage

must be a wings or wild fan if that's what you want

Ya, well, you’re not getting dumba for kapanen + okay prospect + cap dump + junk.

LOL, that was funny. You're not getting Kapanen + Liljegren + SDA for Dumba

Bcarlo assumes most leafs players/prospects are trash.

Dumba would cost Nylander at the very least. The quantity over quality offers are getting pretty ridiculous lately.

So wrong, your statement is ridiculous, the offer proposed is all Quality. You've got Dumba Valued as 1A Dman, he is a 2A 1B at best. I based the trade value on previous trade history on the caliber of player Dumba is - cost has always been a 6/5 F a good prospect and usually a 2nd and 3rd pick - sent over a Top 6 F a great prospect (NHL ready 1st rnd pick) a good C prospect (is developing very very well as play making C) a replacement D to take on minutes on an expiring contract ( if you flip him you'll get a 4th) and a 3rd rnd pick. There is only 1 trade of a RHD of Dumba's caliber that pulled in more and that was Larrson for Hall no gm is using that as a yard stick and no gm will make that mistake again. I'm also completely fine not having Dumba keeping the package and using about half of that package in the offseason to aquire an equally capable RHD

Yep just what the Wild need for Dumba: a 3rd line wing, a cap dump d-man, a non-goal scoring prospect, and a 3rd.

Kapanaen isn't a top-6 FWD on Tor, nor would he be one on MN (Zucker, Zucc, Fiala, Parise are all better than him). Kunin is about equal. Kaprizov comes next year, maybe he light things up and maybe he doesn't, but he needs a roster spot. Boldy will be a long in a couple more years.

Edit. I forgot Lily, which is nice, but doesn't move the needle a lot when MN has 8 d-men on their roster and 2 NHL ready in the AHL.

My statements wrong why exactly? Because one of the biggest Leafs homers on the site says so. Take off the blue glasses for once

You just compared Dumba with Larsson. Any credibility you had left is gone. Good day.