Quoting: SammyT_51
Top-6 two way centerman with scoring qualities able to play against top lines of opposition on a great contract is really high value. Also top-60 pick is big thing too, especially if its 2020 pick which is deeep draft. Pesce is amazing, I would love to stitch his name on Leafs jersey with no2 on below the name and play him with Rielly. That trade would be fair for both sides. Kadri would be great acquisition to any team.
The issue with Kadri is that he's no longer seen as a sure thing to be a top 6 guy on any team. Last summer woulda been more justifiable for that. But right now, as much as he COULD be that, there's not much to back it up. & he certainly doesn't have the value of a top 6 player right now.
1) his production was down this year. 16 goals compared to 32 in each of the last 2 years. Even though he played against weaker opponents this year
2) he has a lengthy suspension/fine history now and at bad times
3) everyone knows Toronto needs to clear cap, you'll never get full value for a guy when the entire league knows that.
Even at full value, Kadri and a 2nd is still a bit off for Pesce. Pesce is younger, on a better contract, and plays a position that's in higher demand (top 4 RHD compared to a middle 6 forward). That just wouldn't be enough to entice Carolina to make the deal.