Vancouver by long shot..

Dahlin > Juolevi
Ristolainen > Hughes (probably)
Eichel > Pettersson
Reinhart < Boeser
Mittlestadt < Horvat (for now)
Nylander = Virtanen

Lose or win idk buffalo is getting the best player back amongst all the players Pettersson to me is the best player in the deal

But overall I can understand why you would say that

petey is better than eichel

buf wins, petey is best player, nylander and reinhart are busts, boeser is amazing

I agree with most of that except for pettersson and eichel. Pettersson is already at a point a game pace in his rookie season and it took Eichel his 4th season to produce over a point a game.

at least someone agrees that petey is better

reinhart is almost scoring a point a game this year. you're an idiot if you think he's a bust.

petey is probably better, my bad

well i guess im an idiot for thinking a player picked 2nd overall should be doing better than 51 points in 58 games, and if im an idiot what does that make you. your the one thinks eichel is better than petey

As a Buffalo fan I can see how BUF wins this trade. Which is really sad because it means BUF is over achieving and VAN has a better future than my Sabres.

nothing wrong with a west team being little bit better in the future

wow a BUF fan admits petey is better

I am not angry nor upset nor is there anything wrong with a west team doing well.
That is not my point, I am sad that as a Sabre's fan my team does not have a bright future and based on this evaluation the Sabres are actually over achieving (not that I ever thought they were a playoff team). But what would one expect after 3 years of DATM rebuild.

I may be a Sabres fan but I am not blind to facts. Elias Pettersson is going to be amazing and next year or the year after Hughes will make the team a playoff team for sure.

Buf has a good future. Eichel,Mittelstadt,Dahlin,Lukkonen,ristolainen,who ever they pick this draft,reinhart and maybe nylander

Eichel = Petey (both are superstars not gonna try to argue one is better than the other)
Reinhart < Horvat (pretty close imo but Bo is extremely well rounded)
Mittelstadt < Boeser (Mittelstadt will hopefully pan out to be a really solid player but Boeser has been a stud)
Nylander < Virtanen (Nylander hasn't established himself as an NHLer and has had average point production in AHL, Virtanen is at least a solid bottom 6 forward)
Dahlin > Hughes (hopefully hughes can become a star but Dahlin is a generational dman)
Ristolainen > Juolevi (once again hopefully juolevi becomes a solid top 4 dman but risto has logged a lot of minutes and been solid for years now)

Nucks have the edge on forwards, BUF on defense. I agree overall it's pretty even and is tough to judge without seeing Juolevi and Hughes at least have a bit of NHL experience.