Minnesota Wild imagine

Toronto definitely matches that. If you want to offer sheet Nylander, get ready to give up 4 1st round picks. We definitely have the assets to trade for him, though. I'd rather not trade for Panarin as a 1 year rental... We give up more than he's worth in that trade even if he is a superstar. CAR trade doesn't really make sense, I'd rather have Spurgeon than Faulk even factoring in age.

Also you only have 20 players on this roster, you have to add 2 forwards and a defenseman for depth

Lol Canes would rather have Faulk than Spurgeon and you want them to give a 2nd?

What’s the point really? Both have 2 years left, Faulk is cheaper, and better. And they have no need for another RD. Brodin maybe. But they want FW or picks for Faulk.

Value-wise, the Faulk/Spurgeon trade makes sense...Faulk is definitely NOT the better!

Here we go again ok lets take a look

Years remainung both 2 push

Aav. faulk 1m cheaper adv faulk

Age faulk 2 years younger adv faulk

82 game averages

Goals faulk 13. spurgeon 9

Assists Faulk 26. Spurgeon 24

Pts Faulk 39. spurgeon 33

Size Faulk 6’1 210. spurgeon 5’8 160

All star games Faulk 3. spurgeon 0

US national teams Faulk 6. Spurgeon 0

Shoud i keep going?

Take off the fan goggles. No gm in hockey would take Spurgeon over Faulk. ....because Faulk is better. It’s not even debatable. Sorry, just fact.

I understand. Every teams fan base over values their own players. They have an emotional attachment to them. Objectivity gets lost. It happens. But you are wrong.