Rejoint: mai 2022
Messages: 9,184
Mentions "j'aime": 3,556
Yeah, making it into a single trade would make more sense but I suspect you just split it up to show what is going for each guy.
The Zadorov trade seems reasonable but I think the Leafs should keep Topi as their Dcore is aging and they don't got too many guys, maybe Robertson can be dealt there instead. I don't think he will end up being in the Leafs top 6 in the future even if he does end up there for a year or two, so there isn't really much space for him. CGY might not want more small forwards but who knows?
I think it's too much for Tanev, if a 1st has to be given for him and the Leafs think they need him then, it should be a 1st+4th for Tanev at 50% max. Personally, I don't think it's worth it for the Leafs to pay that much for him unless they are flipping Liljegren elsewhere for a 1st (not sure that is even possible still). Giving two 2nds+4th as they did for Giordano would be more favorable. Maybe something like Timmins + a 2nd + a 4th (could have a condition that the 2nd turns into a 1st if the Leafs win the Cup) since they aren't playing him in this scenario.